news

U.S. Congresswoman Debbie Dingell (MI-12) today joined 195 House colleagues in sending a letter to President Trump reminding him that millions of working families around the nation are relying on him to continue paying the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) cost-sharing reduction (CSR) payments. Since taking office, President Trump has raised doubts about the future of these payments, which help seven million hardworking Americans and their families afford their out-of-pocket health care costs, such as deductibles and copays, through the ACA Marketplace.

“Ensuring every American has access to affordable, quality health insurance should be a shared goal for the President and every Member of Congress,” said Dingell. “Stopping these cost-sharing reduction payments, which are required by law, could put health insurance out of reach for families in Michigan and across the country. It is critical that the President fulfill his obligation to make these payments and stop all other acts of sabotage that could result in millions of Americans losing access to care.”

In Michigan, 164,700 people currently benefit from the cost-sharing subsidies. The President’s failure to commit to paying these subsidies is destabilizing the Marketplaces, and will directly result in higher health care costs and insurance companies pulling out of the Marketplace, leading to fewer consumer choices. If the Marketplace is destabilized, 313,100 Michiganders who purchased high quality Marketplace coverage would face higher health care costs and fewer choices. 

“The decision to unilaterally rescind support for these subsidies will cause premiums and out-of-pocket costs to skyrocket and could cause millions of Americans to lose their health insurance coverage,” Dingell and her colleagues wrote.  “Insurers have little time left to finalize their rate filings for 2018, and without certainty as to whether or not cost-sharing subsidies will be paid, they will significantly raise their rates or exit the Marketplaces altogether.”  

In April, a report from the Kaiser Family Foundation estimated that insurance premiums for certain plans would need to increase by 19 percent to compensate for the lack of funding for cost-sharing subsidies.

“Working families in every state are relying on you to pay cost-sharing subsidies to help ensure that they can afford the health care they need,” the Members wrote. “The stability of the nation’s health care system and the health of millions of Americans now rest in your hands. Their health care coverage is not a bargaining chip.” 

Full text of the letter to President Trump can be found below:

May 24, 2017

The President

The White House

Washington, D.C. 20500

Dear Mr. President:

The law requires, and it is your obligation under the law, to pay the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) cost-sharing reduction payments.  Equivocation on this matter destabilizes the market and hurts American families by directly increasing their health care costs. 

Cost-sharing reduction payments help seven million hardworking Americans and their families – more than half of all Marketplace enrollees for 2017 – afford their out-of-pocket health care costs.  The decision to unilaterally rescind support for these subsidies will cause premiums and out-of-pocket costs to skyrocket and could cause millions of Americans to lose their health insurance coverage. 

According to a recent report in Politico, your administration has stated that it will continue to pay these cost-sharing subsidies, for now.   However, your public statements continue to raise doubts about the future of these payments and your commitment to enforcing the ACA, the law of the land.   You have also stated in the past that, “The best thing politically is to let Obamacare explode” and recently said that “Obamacare is dead.”   

We strongly disagree.  The ACA is not dead; however, your failure to commit to paying these subsidies is destabilizing the Marketplaces, and will directly result in higher costs and fewer consumer choices.  Insurers have little time left to finalize their rate filings for 2018, and without certainty as to whether or not cost-sharing subsidies will be paid, they will significantly raise their rates or exit the Marketplaces altogether.  According to the American Academy of Actuaries, failure to make cost-sharing subsidy payments “could result in insurer losses and solvency challenges, leading insurers to further consider withdrawing from the market. . . . [S]ignificant market disruption could result, leading to millions of Americans losing their health insurance.”   In fact, the CEO of Molina Healthcare recently warned that if cost-sharing subsidies are not funded, the company will withdraw from the Marketplaces immediately.  

In areas where insurers decide to remain in the Marketplaces, failure to pay these subsidies will increase premiums for all individuals enrolled in the individual market.  According to a study by the Kaiser Family Foundation, average ACA Marketplace premiums for silver plans would need to increase by 19 percent to compensate for lack of funding for cost-sharing subsidies.   An analysis conducted by Covered California found that 2018 health premiums in the individual market in California could rise by 42-49 percent if the subsidies are not funded and other provisions of the ACA are not enforced.   Rising prices and fewer choices will likely hit consumers in rural areas, where health care prices have traditionally been higher, particularly hard.   As a result of rising premiums, the federal government would end up spending $31 billion more from 2018-2027. 

Working families in every state are relying on you to pay cost-sharing subsidies to help ensure that they can afford the health care they need.  The stability of the nation’s health care system and the health of millions of Americans now rest in your hands.  Their health care coverage is not a bargaining chip. 

It is your responsibility to the American people and your obligation under the law to make the cost-sharing reduction payments and to stop other acts of sabotage that undermine Americans’ access to affordable, quality health insurance.

Sincerely,